Roquefort, caught in the cross-fire
A cheese held hostage? Non – mais, oui! Last week it was announced that as of March 23rd, 2009, a 300% duty will take effect on all French Roquefort cheese imported into North America. Currently at a 100% duty, this sheep’s milk cheese produced in caves north of Montpelier, will soon triple in price. The real issue is a complex tangle of rulings and rebuffs dating back a dozen years. It is all about beef: hormone treated beef from North America has been banned from European Union markets. European Union farmers have not been allowed to use hormones in raising livestock since 1989, a measure taken for health reasons as well as concerns about run-off from manure on farms where hormones were used. Water quality and environmental questions were involved. Central to the ruling were questions about the effect on children’s growth (early puberty, etc.) of eating hormone-raised beef during childhood. Out of the six hormones in question, one has been found harmful/carcinogenic; the remaining five are labeled “precautionary”. But the World Trade Organization ruling on this EU ban cited insufficient scientific proof of the health implications. Europe’s farmers are enraged, have raised their voices in protest. Next week’s French Agriculture Fair in Paris will provide a forum for their viewpoints. And there will be viewpoints: in 2007, 3,800 tonnes of Roquefort was shipped to the US, the third largest market for this veined cheese. It has been taxed at 100% for nine years. A list of European Union products to carry 100% duty include chocolate, pork, pears, truffles, hams, oats, truffles, mineral water, and French mustard (see Mustard Woes post of November 2008). A North American official stated that the intent of these high duties is: “to shut down trade in target imports”. So, next time Steck-frites, sauce Roquefort (Steak topped with roquefort sauce, a side of French fries) is on the menu, think about it….and check the price.
Note: vagabondgourmand will dig for more facts on this, to be noted in this space. For further information, check the following: www.sustainabletable.org/issues/hormones, http://ictsd.net/i/news for International Centre for Trade & Sustainable Development, www.wto.org/english/news for World Trade Organization.





